Facebook Twitter Instagram
    India Art Review
    • Dance
    • Music
    • Art
    • Heritage
    • Theatre
    • Books
    • Films
    • Team
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    India Art Review
    Home»Film»Does India need a Censor Board?
    Film

    Does India need a Censor Board?

    India Art ReviewBy India Art ReviewDecember 17, 2020
    Share
    WhatsApp Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram

    As its recent actions illustrate, the certification body is an anachronism in a modern democracy like India

    Just a few days ago, India’s Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) asked the directors of Bengali film ‘Dekh Kemon Lage’ to mute the word ‘Radha’ in one of the songs in the feature film. The government body headed by Pahlaj Nihalani, who happens to be the director and producer of, among others, “Mera Desh Mahaan”, a music video as a tribute to Prime Minister Modi. A few weeks ago, the CBFC, popularly known as the Censor Board, objected to certain words in a documentary on Nobel-winning economist Amartya Sen, directed by Suman Ghosh. The board wanted to mute words such as ‘cow’, ‘Hindutva’ “Hindu India”, “Hindutva view of India” and “Gujarat” from the documentary ‘The Argumentative Indian’ if the film was to get a clean ‘U’ (view-for-all) certificate. Ghosh and the producers of the documentary said they would fight the decision. Some time ago, again, the Censor Board hesitated to clear the film “Lipstick Under My Burkha” by Alankrita Shrivastava. The ‘bold’ film was nearly rejected by the CBFC and the producers approached the Film Certification Appellate Tribunal (FCAT). FCAT finally asked the CBFC to grant the film an ‘A’ certificate.

    But not everyone picks up a battle with the board. Many choose to give in to the pressure. After Nihalani took up the reins of the CBFC, several controversies erupted, causing enough headache for filmmakers in the country, triggering a debate on whether the very existence of the CBFC has become an aberration to the idea of India itself. Is the Censor Board doing the right thing by introducing stricter rules and guidelines? It’s history shows the other way.

    The CBFC is a statutory body functioning under the Information and Broadcasting ministry. It regulates public exhibition of films under the provisions of the Cinematograph Act of 1952. All films need the CBFC certification to be screened in the country. There is no doubt that the body, which still goes by rules set almost six decades ago and rarely updated, needs a revamp and it should be functioning like a modern art certification body rather than a censoring apparatus. In 2016, a special committee headed by filmmaker Shyam Benegal had suggested that CBFC should limit its functioning to issuing certificates to movies and not impose censoring. The Benegal committee was set up to “suggest a holistic framework for certification of films and recommend a framework that would provide efficient and transparent user-friendly services”. The committee had put forward several radical suggestions in sync with the modern times, but the recommendations are still lying in the Government’s cold storage.

    Benegal recently told media that he was hopeful that the Modi government would push the much required revamping of the CBFC and amend the archaic Cinematograph Act 1952. Interestingly, the Benegal committee had urged the CBFC to introduce a new category called ‘adult with caution’ and classifying the existing categories into UA 12+ and UA 15+ to make the content accessible to appropriate audience. But it seems Benegal is hoping against hope. Nihalani has told media that Benegal is not demanding the “right things”. He prefers cuts while certifying film. Nihalani doesn’t buy the idea that the CBFC is just a certifying body. He says it is a wrong interpretation by “unknowledgeable people”. According to him, there’s an act and rulebook also, “which you can’t forget”.

    There is a draft bill aimed at amending the Cinematography Act has proposed to curtail the CBFC’s powers to make filmmakers modify or delete content. But filmmakers suspect it won’t see the light of the day anytime soon given the current regime’s penchant for controlling art expressions. They cite the global best practices in this regard. Censorship rules as they are practised today are anti-modern and archaic. The new recommendations follow the norms of the American Association, which are flexible and suitably democratic. Of course, there should be warnings of all sorts — of bad language, violence, sex and similar content, but ultimately it should be left to the viewer’s discretion whether to watch the film or not, the State should stay away from any kind of control or interference.

    Filmmakers believe censoring impinges on the freedom of expression and is not suitable in a plural democracy such as India. In fact, former Union I&B minister M Venkaiah Naidu, who is set to become the country’s Vice-President, had said the Government agreed with most recommendations of the Benegal report and would make the amendments. But now with Naidu gone and Modi loyalist Smriti Irani, known for her conservative views on art and education, taking charge as the new I&B minister, what will happen to the idea of modernising the CBFC can be anybody’s guess.

    censorship films
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Previous ArticleLines, Dots, Colour and the Six Seasons
    Next Article Gulabo Sitabo: Amitabh meets Ayushmann
    India Art Review
    India Art Review

      Related Posts

      Meiyazhagan

      Tracing Nostalgia Through Meiyazhagan

      April 17, 2025
      Violence in movies

      The Aesthetics of Violence: Art or Sensationalism?

      March 2, 2025
      MT

      Those precious moments with MT

      January 11, 2025

      Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

      Author In Focus VK Karthika

      Pathaan

      Pathaan: A Triumph of Love Over Hate

      V K KarthikaMarch 31, 2023

      Pathaan breaks the typical stereotype of Islamic Terrorism.

      Avatar

      Eastern Ethos Lifts up Cameron’s Avatar Sequel

      V K KarthikaJanuary 31, 2023

      Eastern ethos and laws of the nature are set to get a new tech-driven meaning as Cameron is planning two more sequels.

      Yazh

      Reviving Yazh, the Indian Harp

      V K KarthikaNovember 28, 2022

      Without Tharun, Yazh, an ancient instrument would not have taken birth in modern times

      Tholppavakoothu

      Girl Power up in Puppetry

      V K KarthikaSeptember 30, 2022

      Rajitha Ramachandra Pulavar and her team gave a new meaning to Tholppavakkooth and the body politics went in for a change in 2021

      Nanjiyamma tribal singer of Attappady

      Why the National Award for Tribal Singer Nanjiyamma Matters

      V K KarthikaAugust 27, 2022

      India witnessed a debate on the ‘purity of music’ when tribal singer Nanjiyamma won the National Award.

      EVENTS

      Nangiyarkoothu

      Celebrating 60 Years of Dance Excellence

      India Art ReviewMay 23, 2025

      Swara-dhi: A Soulful Summer Camp for Music Connoisseurs

      India Art ReviewMay 23, 2025
      Sooryakanthi festival

      Sooryakanthi Dance Festival From Nov 28- Dec 1

      India Art ReviewNovember 25, 2024

      Memorial Awards and Dance Performances in Chennai

      India Art ReviewNovember 25, 2024

      Have You Read These?

      Youth

      The Fountain of Youth

      Vineeth AbrahamMay 16, 2023

      What will happen when a bookworm set out to clean his library? One of the…

      The Elephant Whisperers

      Poetics of Fostering the Animal: The Elephant Whisperers

      Babu Rajan P PMay 1, 2023

      With the decline of natural habitats, human-elephant conflict has seen a surge, often leaving the majestic creatures as unwitting participants. “The Elephant Whisperers” documentary pays homage to the conservation endeavors aimed at preserving these habitats and raising awareness among communities about the perils of anthropocentrism.

      1899 and the Virtual Studio: Futuristic Filmmaking

      IAR DeskMarch 12, 2023

      1899, the new web series from the creators of German masterpiece Dark, will be filmed entirely in a virtual studio. Here’s all you wanted to know about ‘Volume’ and why it matters to futuristic filmmaking.

      Yazh

      Reviving Yazh, the Indian Harp

      V K KarthikaNovember 28, 2022

      Without Tharun, Yazh, an ancient instrument would not have taken birth in modern times

      A ‘Lyrical Dance’ Tribute to Edassery’s Poem

      G S PaulNovember 8, 2022

      Choreographic ingenuity of Vinitha Nedungadi created alluring visuals of the sublime poetic imagination of Edassery in Anthithiri.

      vijayakumar menon

      Vijayakumar Menon Taught Kerala How to Appreciate Art

      Renu RamanathNovember 3, 2022

      The only wealth Menon amassed during his solitary journey was that of art. When Vijayakumar…

      About
      About

      India Art Review is a dedicated digital journal of art and culture, based in Chennai and with representatives in Kerala, Delhi, the UAE, Canada and the US.

      We're social, connect with us:

      Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedIn Telegram
      People in Art
      Kishori Amonkar: A Class Apart

      Kishori Amonkar: A Class Apart

      April 3, 2021
      NP Ramaswamy: Carnatic Vocalist, Lyricist and Composer

      NP Ramaswamy: Carnatic Vocalist, Lyricist and Composer

      November 5, 2020
      Fr. Paul Poovathingal: Singing Priest With a Healing Voice

      Fr. Paul Poovathingal: Singing Priest With a Healing Voice

      May 25, 2021
      Shobhana Rangachari: A Lesser-Known Carnatic Vocalist

      Shobhana Rangachari: A Lesser-Known Carnatic Vocalist

      October 25, 2020
      Must Reads
      Mangad Natesan

      Remembering Carnatic Musician Mangad Natesan

      May 3, 2024
      P K G Nambiar

      PKG Nambiar(1930-2023): The Man who Redefined the Role of Vidooshaka

      May 10, 2023
      Kanak Rele

      Dr. Kanak Rele (1937-2023): A Revolutionary in Dance 

      February 22, 2023
      Pandit Shivkumar Sharma

      Adieu, Pandit Shivkumar Sharma

      May 10, 2022
      Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube RSS
      • Home
      • About
      Copyright © 2022. India Art Review

      Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.