Facebook Twitter Instagram
    India Art Review
    • Dance
    • Music
    • Art
    • Heritage
    • Theatre
    • Books
    • Films
    • Team
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    India Art Review
    Home»Film»The Disciple: Aesthetics of Mediocrity
    Film

    The Disciple: Aesthetics of Mediocrity

    Anuj DagaBy Anuj DagaApril 5, 2022
    Chaitanya Tamhane The Disciple
    Share
    WhatsApp Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram

    Chaitanya Tamhane’s The Disciple explores the burden of self-expectation and the price one pays for a perceived notion of mediocrity.

    Chaitanya Tamhane’s The Disciple, released in May 2020, charts the life of Sharad Nerulkar (Aditya Modak), an aspiring classical vocalist in the Hindustani music tradition. Sharad is a devoted learner under his guru who trains young minds in music while giving vocal performances that earn him his modest survival.

    While the other students learning under the Guru along with Sharad find themselves platforms for performance as they graduate, Sharad seems to be struggling, caught up in mere technique and finding it difficult to creatively breakthrough into the art itself. Sharad is fully aware of his shortcomings. He is self-critical, hardworking and, yet, an unsuccessful individual. In such a narration, the film, as largely understood by most, is about “coming to terms with one’s own mediocrity”.

    What lies behind the appeal of the film is Tamhane’s ability to produce empathy towards a deeply undesired human value: mediocrity. Whether you want it or not, the film brings an element of doubt in our abilities. This production of ambiguity is the hallmark of Tamhanhe’s film-making, in techniques as well as storytelling. The sustained long-distance shots in the film don’t try to direct the eye too much, but rather suspend the viewer in the ambiguity of space itself.

    Chaitanya Tamhane (left)

    The illusion of perfection

    The voice of the inner mind — in Maai’s recordings plugged into Sharad’s ears as he strolls through the empty streets of the city at night, or his own confusion trying to come to terms with his perceived shortcomings or the seeming politics of his relationship with his guru — create the haunt of ambiguous space. The constructed silences amplify the frustrations of a mind that is unable to articulate the means to reach the genius.

    To be sure, the storytelling in The Disciple has the exact opposite effect of what Taare Zameen Par (directed by Aamir Khan and Amol Gupte, 2007) had on us. In contrast to how we all relate to the young dyslexic boy in TZP and imagine that we are special too, Sharad’s character in The Disciple is quite anticlimactic.

    Tamhane forces us to consider through the film whether the figure of the genius is reality or myth. What triggers the failure of the disciple in the film? His shortcomings? Or lack of opportunities?  

    Such opportunities are controlled by networks, connections, access to people, and so on. To be fair, the disciple, Sharad, did not seem so bad. He had the technique, skill and he was intelligent enough to understand his limitations. Then why should he have suffered? To know what you don’t know is a good thing, but did the idealism of his Maai pull him back from believing in himself to even find an alternative space for his craft?

    Sharad ends up giving so much importance to the aura of the world that Maai creates for him, that he stops acknowledging his reality, the context in which he lives. Perhaps, the slippage that he suffers in his life is the burden of self-expectation.

    What could have been the role of the guru in shaping a student such as Sharad who is honest, hardworking, self-critical yet unable to design music through his craft? We do not see the guru’s efforts in devising methods for his student to be able to produce new experiences or overcome his mental block. While the incapability of the student has been highlighted throughout the film, the responsibility of the teacher could have been detailed too. The pedagogical zone of music is left mythically illusive, excused in complete devotion, abstinence or sacrifice. Sharad refrains from worldly pleasures until a late age despite having strong carnal urges.

    The idea of success

    The film forces one to look at ‘mediocrity’ as a social construct. How must one prepare a frame for critical appraisal of averageness? The ‘everyday’ is a category that may be one window to the acknowledgement of being average – which is neither good nor bad. Isn’t that what average is? Average is functional, workable, acceptable, and satisfactory. Sharad was satisfactory. For most of our lives, we consume what is satisfactory. The desire to be exclusive and special is a socially constructed desire. I don’t mean to suggest that one should not have the desire to feel special or be exclusive.

    The argument however is, why does ‘average’ bring discomfort to us even if the majority of the population is just plain average? How have we come to ascribe a negative value to being average? Is there no beauty in the average? It is the rejection of the average that Sharad’s mind is conflicted with. Sharad’s conflict may also be seen as valid because he has been putting in tremendous personal resources to go beyond the average. Yet, I wish the guru was able to help Sharad reconcile with his averageness. Over time, the film expresses the aesthetic of mediocrity rather beautifully.

    Sharad – once a young charming boy reluctantly hopeful of a bright future in his eyes slowly emerges into a stiff middle-aged man drowned in the seriousness of life and failure of his ambition. He is certainly not progressive and holds the values he has come to believe in (without critical consideration) rather strongly. That mindset becomes his frame to judge the world, a world that he feels judged by.

    Sharad is confused about the idea of success – he is unable to resolve whether it is the worldly acknowledgement or the internal contentment through his singing that will satisfy his restiveness. In his case, perhaps these categories are intertwined and interrelated. His belief in a purism that he could not bring in his music never deters him from it. Still, Sharad does not alter his route from the Hindustani classical form despite having tremendous technique. He prefers to remain in limbo without the methods or means to achieve success or salvation in his art. This, in my mind, was my biggest dejection in Sharad.

    Beyond benchmarks

    A stronger Marxist analysis of the film would bring out how values of mediocrity or averageness, which often become the frames of self-identification, are a result of the political economy of how the enterprise of classical music organizes itself in the present-day context. Matters of exposure, access, patronage, and support are all reworked through distinct mechanisms of the economy. Value is largely created through quantified logistics.

    How do we trust instruments of TRPs or the uninformed ears/eyes that hold the power to bring value to artistic pursuits that take a lifetime to be honed? The mysticism associated with the values of the ‘genius’ or ‘excellence’ may operate well in a medieval economic model, however, when brought into the space of capitalism may require new grounding.

    Yet, the question of where do we locate art, its purpose – for the self and the world, are questions that the film helps open up. The film could have exposed us to other dimensions of Sharad’s life beyond music, which in its portrayal not only makes us view him as a loser, but could also help us enjoy the fact that average is beautiful.

    Write to us at [email protected]

    academic studies on films chaitany tamhane film analysis film essay film review films Hindi film reviews Indian films Netflix film review the disciple
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Previous ArticleRemembering Chummar Choondal
    Next Article Alolitha and Dhrutha: The Occult Origins of Mohiniyattam – Part 41
    Anuj Daga
    Anuj Daga

      Anuj Daga is an architect, writer and curator based in Mumbai. Anuj has worked with several cultural institutions including Max Mueller Bhavan Mumbai, MoMA – New York, CAMP – Mumbai, Godrej Innovation Centre and Serendipity Arts Foundation in different capacities. Currently an Assistant Professor at the School of Environment & Architecture, Mumbai, Anuj has a keen interest in studying the processes of visual culture and meaning-making in the contemporary built environment in South Asia.

      Related Posts

      Meiyazhagan

      Tracing Nostalgia Through Meiyazhagan

      April 17, 2025
      Violence in movies

      The Aesthetics of Violence: Art or Sensationalism?

      March 2, 2025
      The Old Man and the Sea

      The Old Man and the Sea: Reinterpreting Hemingway in Kathakali

      February 28, 2025

      Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

      Author In Focus VK Karthika

      Pathaan

      Pathaan: A Triumph of Love Over Hate

      V K KarthikaMarch 31, 2023

      Pathaan breaks the typical stereotype of Islamic Terrorism.

      Avatar

      Eastern Ethos Lifts up Cameron’s Avatar Sequel

      V K KarthikaJanuary 31, 2023

      Eastern ethos and laws of the nature are set to get a new tech-driven meaning as Cameron is planning two more sequels.

      Yazh

      Reviving Yazh, the Indian Harp

      V K KarthikaNovember 28, 2022

      Without Tharun, Yazh, an ancient instrument would not have taken birth in modern times

      Tholppavakoothu

      Girl Power up in Puppetry

      V K KarthikaSeptember 30, 2022

      Rajitha Ramachandra Pulavar and her team gave a new meaning to Tholppavakkooth and the body politics went in for a change in 2021

      Nanjiyamma tribal singer of Attappady

      Why the National Award for Tribal Singer Nanjiyamma Matters

      V K KarthikaAugust 27, 2022

      India witnessed a debate on the ‘purity of music’ when tribal singer Nanjiyamma won the National Award.

      EVENTS

      Nangiyarkoothu

      Celebrating 60 Years of Dance Excellence

      India Art ReviewMay 23, 2025

      Swara-dhi: A Soulful Summer Camp for Music Connoisseurs

      India Art ReviewMay 23, 2025
      Sooryakanthi festival

      Sooryakanthi Dance Festival From Nov 28- Dec 1

      India Art ReviewNovember 25, 2024

      Memorial Awards and Dance Performances in Chennai

      India Art ReviewNovember 25, 2024

      Have You Read These?

      Youth

      The Fountain of Youth

      Vineeth AbrahamMay 16, 2023

      What will happen when a bookworm set out to clean his library? One of the…

      The Elephant Whisperers

      Poetics of Fostering the Animal: The Elephant Whisperers

      Babu Rajan P PMay 1, 2023

      With the decline of natural habitats, human-elephant conflict has seen a surge, often leaving the majestic creatures as unwitting participants. “The Elephant Whisperers” documentary pays homage to the conservation endeavors aimed at preserving these habitats and raising awareness among communities about the perils of anthropocentrism.

      1899 and the Virtual Studio: Futuristic Filmmaking

      IAR DeskMarch 12, 2023

      1899, the new web series from the creators of German masterpiece Dark, will be filmed entirely in a virtual studio. Here’s all you wanted to know about ‘Volume’ and why it matters to futuristic filmmaking.

      Yazh

      Reviving Yazh, the Indian Harp

      V K KarthikaNovember 28, 2022

      Without Tharun, Yazh, an ancient instrument would not have taken birth in modern times

      A ‘Lyrical Dance’ Tribute to Edassery’s Poem

      G S PaulNovember 8, 2022

      Choreographic ingenuity of Vinitha Nedungadi created alluring visuals of the sublime poetic imagination of Edassery in Anthithiri.

      vijayakumar menon

      Vijayakumar Menon Taught Kerala How to Appreciate Art

      Renu RamanathNovember 3, 2022

      The only wealth Menon amassed during his solitary journey was that of art. When Vijayakumar…

      About
      About

      India Art Review is a dedicated digital journal of art and culture, based in Chennai and with representatives in Kerala, Delhi, the UAE, Canada and the US.

      We're social, connect with us:

      Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedIn Telegram
      People in Art
      ML Vasanthakumari MLV: The Doyenne of Melody, Laya and Vidhvatta

      MLV: The Doyenne of Melody, Laya and Vidhvatta

      July 3, 2021
      Malini Rajurkar: A Hindustani Vocalist’s Unparalleled Journey

      Malini Rajurkar: A Hindustani Vocalist’s Unparalleled Journey

      January 8, 2021
      Kalamandalam Kalyanikutty Amma: The Only Matriarch of Mohiniyattam

      Kalamandalam Kalyanikutty Amma: The Only Matriarch of Mohiniyattam

      May 12, 2021
      Annapurna Devi & Chitti Babu: No Heads or Tails

      Annapurna Devi & Chitti Babu: No Heads or Tails

      October 20, 2020
      Must Reads
      Mangad Natesan

      Remembering Carnatic Musician Mangad Natesan

      May 3, 2024
      P K G Nambiar

      PKG Nambiar(1930-2023): The Man who Redefined the Role of Vidooshaka

      May 10, 2023
      Kanak Rele

      Dr. Kanak Rele (1937-2023): A Revolutionary in Dance 

      February 22, 2023
      Pandit Shivkumar Sharma

      Adieu, Pandit Shivkumar Sharma

      May 10, 2022
      Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube RSS
      • Home
      • About
      Copyright © 2022. India Art Review

      Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.