Facebook Twitter Instagram
    India Art Review
    • Dance
    • Music
    • Art
    • Heritage
    • Theatre
    • Books
    • Films
    • Team
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    India Art Review
    Home»Music»East and West: Philosophy of Musical Traditions
    Music

    East and West: Philosophy of Musical Traditions

    G S PaulBy G S PaulJune 21, 2022
    Carnatic music
    Share
    WhatsApp Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram

    How the harmonic music of the West and the melodic music of the East differ in its basic philosophy

    It has been widely accepted that there are only two musical traditions in the whole world that are complete in themselves. They are the classical Indian music and classical western music. The two systems have striking similarities as well as contrasts.

    The similarities are inevitable because of the universal appeal of music that transcends geographical, linguistic and cultural barriers. But the differences emerge as music reflects the degree and character of consciousness peculiar to the cultural sphere it springs from. Also, it depicts the thinking and feeling of the people in the historical epoch in which it is produced.

    Common origin 

    It is interesting to note that both European and Indian systems of music followed the same track till the 15th century. Music was a means of communication between man and God as soon as it attained the status of an art. The accent during those days was not on the personal but on the impersonal.

    The absence of consciousness of ego or self presupposes the absence of a consciousness about space. This is because space has relevance only when it is correlated to the observer or the subject. As the medieval man was neutral and indifferent towards space, his music also was correspondingly plain and flat as found in the Vedic chants, Gregorian chants and the choral music.

    But during the periods of Renaissance, Classicism and Romanticism and also during the final stages of Impressionism and Expressionism, there was an attempt to place man at the centre of the whole system. Thus the world around him began to be treated as an object seen by him, heard by him and experienced by him. Human attitude thus changed from a contemplative to a pragmatic one. Music began expressing man’s feelings. No longer was its function to communicate to the Divine, but communication of ‘pleasure’.

    Harmony Vs Melody

    The one-dimensional music of the West changed to a two-dimensional one with the advent of harmony and chords. Music attained a third dimension of ‘tonality’ in later years which represented the organisation of all the tones and chords of a piece of music in relation to the tonic – the harmonic leading tone.

    In sharp contrast to the rational, discursive Western music that appeals mainly to the intellect, Indian counterpart is intuitive. Its appeal is to emotion.

    The mono-dimensional aspect of Indian music can be attributed to the absence of a rational consciousness of space which is discernible even in the architecture of our temples. Unlike the Cathedrals of the West, they do not embody space, but contain undifferentiated and cosmic space. This is reminiscent of the sublime cosmological conception according to which the universe itself is nothing but a tremendous cavern of which the temple is a prototype.

    Since space and time condition each other, time in Indian music is psychical and emotional. It is the natural and experienced time whose metric unit is the natural heart-beat of man.

    Our musicians concentrate on the swinging of pitch between the centres of each note whereas the Westerner jumps from one to the other. Notes swimming continuously in the sea of sound when brought together and arranged according to particular patterns, are called ragas; each having its proper season, day and hour of performance. When so performed, the raga is believed to have the power to move the elements of nature, in man and even in animal. And the history of Indian music is replete with stories depicting the power of ragas.

    On the contrary, Western music was influenced by the dialectical thinking that has dominated the Western thought ever since the days of Plato and Aristotle. It consists in counter positioning of thesis and antithesis from which a third, known as synthesis is derived. The opposing terms of consonance and dissonance, major and minor, melody and counterpoint, tonic and dominant – all give rise to tension leading to a synthesis which completes the unity of the work.

    But the conflict of contrasts that leads to dramatic tension is strange to Indian music. Here the contrasting terms rotate round the central point namely raga thereby complimenting each other to form a whole.

    Harmony Indian Classical Music Melody Music Tradition Raga Rythm Western Classical Music World Music Day
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Previous ArticleAnother String to the Bow
    Next Article Thaganam Adavu: The Occult Origins of Mohiniyattam- 52
    GS Paul
    G S Paul

      GS Paul is an eminent art columnist and critic. He has been writing for national dailies such as The Hindu for more than three decades. Currently, he is the Editorial Advisor of India Art Review.

      Related Posts

      Talat Mahmood

      Talat Mahmood: The King Of Ghazals

      May 9, 2025
      Pandit Budhaditya Mukherjee

      String by String: The Dream of a Sound and the Making of a Sitar

      April 7, 2025
      Bansuri

      Mastering the Bansuri

      February 18, 2025

      3 Comments

      1. Dr.+K.+Radhakrishnan on June 21, 2022 2:37 pm

        Excellent

        Reply
        • India Art Review
          India Art Review on June 22, 2022 6:05 pm

          Thank you Sir

          Reply
      2. Dr Unnikrishnan Pulikkal on June 22, 2022 7:34 pm

        Beautiful piece of prose. Very original and profound thoughts.

        Reply

      Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

      Author In Focus VK Karthika

      Pathaan

      Pathaan: A Triumph of Love Over Hate

      V K KarthikaMarch 31, 2023

      Pathaan breaks the typical stereotype of Islamic Terrorism.

      Avatar

      Eastern Ethos Lifts up Cameron’s Avatar Sequel

      V K KarthikaJanuary 31, 2023

      Eastern ethos and laws of the nature are set to get a new tech-driven meaning as Cameron is planning two more sequels.

      Yazh

      Reviving Yazh, the Indian Harp

      V K KarthikaNovember 28, 2022

      Without Tharun, Yazh, an ancient instrument would not have taken birth in modern times

      Tholppavakoothu

      Girl Power up in Puppetry

      V K KarthikaSeptember 30, 2022

      Rajitha Ramachandra Pulavar and her team gave a new meaning to Tholppavakkooth and the body politics went in for a change in 2021

      Nanjiyamma tribal singer of Attappady

      Why the National Award for Tribal Singer Nanjiyamma Matters

      V K KarthikaAugust 27, 2022

      India witnessed a debate on the ‘purity of music’ when tribal singer Nanjiyamma won the National Award.

      EVENTS

      Sooryakanthi festival

      Sooryakanthi Dance Festival From Nov 28- Dec 1

      India Art ReviewNovember 25, 2024

      Memorial Awards and Dance Performances in Chennai

      India Art ReviewNovember 25, 2024

      Tribute to Yamini Krishnamurthy

      India Art ReviewAugust 13, 2024

      Kuchipudi Drama

      India Art ReviewMay 24, 2024

      Have You Read These?

      Youth

      The Fountain of Youth

      Vineeth AbrahamMay 16, 2023

      What will happen when a bookworm set out to clean his library? One of the…

      The Elephant Whisperers

      Poetics of Fostering the Animal: The Elephant Whisperers

      Babu Rajan P PMay 1, 2023

      With the decline of natural habitats, human-elephant conflict has seen a surge, often leaving the majestic creatures as unwitting participants. “The Elephant Whisperers” documentary pays homage to the conservation endeavors aimed at preserving these habitats and raising awareness among communities about the perils of anthropocentrism.

      1899 and the Virtual Studio: Futuristic Filmmaking

      IAR DeskMarch 12, 2023

      1899, the new web series from the creators of German masterpiece Dark, will be filmed entirely in a virtual studio. Here’s all you wanted to know about ‘Volume’ and why it matters to futuristic filmmaking.

      Yazh

      Reviving Yazh, the Indian Harp

      V K KarthikaNovember 28, 2022

      Without Tharun, Yazh, an ancient instrument would not have taken birth in modern times

      A ‘Lyrical Dance’ Tribute to Edassery’s Poem

      G S PaulNovember 8, 2022

      Choreographic ingenuity of Vinitha Nedungadi created alluring visuals of the sublime poetic imagination of Edassery in Anthithiri.

      vijayakumar menon

      Vijayakumar Menon Taught Kerala How to Appreciate Art

      Renu RamanathNovember 3, 2022

      The only wealth Menon amassed during his solitary journey was that of art. When Vijayakumar…

      About
      About

      India Art Review is a dedicated digital journal of art and culture, based in Chennai and with representatives in Kerala, Delhi, the UAE, Canada and the US.

      We're social, connect with us:

      Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube LinkedIn Telegram
      People in Art

      K N Haridas: A Painter with a Passion for European Churches

      August 5, 2021
      Ustad Amir Khan: A True Nadayogi

      Ustad Amir Khan: A True Nadayogi

      February 13, 2021
      Yuko Matoba: Vainika from the Land of the Rising Sun

      Yuko Matoba: Vainika from the Land of the Rising Sun

      March 18, 2021
      V.S.N: The First Music Critic of Kerala

      V.S.N: The First Music Critic of Kerala

      July 1, 2021
      Must Reads
      Mangad Natesan

      Remembering Carnatic Musician Mangad Natesan

      May 3, 2024
      P K G Nambiar

      PKG Nambiar(1930-2023): The Man who Redefined the Role of Vidooshaka

      May 10, 2023
      Kanak Rele

      Dr. Kanak Rele (1937-2023): A Revolutionary in Dance 

      February 22, 2023
      Pandit Shivkumar Sharma

      Adieu, Pandit Shivkumar Sharma

      May 10, 2022
      Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube RSS
      • Home
      • About
      Copyright © 2022. India Art Review

      Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.